HR and Workforce · Researched comparison

How to Pick App Onboarding Best Practices: 6 Tools Compared

TaskReports may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Personalisation with Appcues is the first pick on this list for branching flows by user segment. Permission priming with OneSignal fits asking for notifications at the right moment; Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel fits letting users reach the core action first. The other 3 tools in the list cover narrower or pricier cases.

On this page

Key takeaways

  • Top of the list is Personalisation with Appcues, which targets branching flows by user segment.
  • Re-engagement with Customer.io fits winning back users who stalled.
  • Check the limits for Permission priming with OneSignal before you commit: Priming cannot fix a notification strategy users do not want.
  • The lowest published monthly entry price here is $29 per seat per month, from Checklists with Intercom.
  • 3 of 6 tools offer a free plan: Permission priming with OneSignal, Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel, Flow experiments with Firebase.

Quick comparison

ToolStarts atFree planVendor site
------------
Personalisation with AppcuesSee websiteNoappcues.com
Permission priming with OneSignalFreeYesonesignal.com
Value before signup, measured in MixpanelFreeYesmixpanel.com
Checklists with Intercom$29 per seat per monthNointercom.com
Flow experiments with FirebaseFreeYesfirebase.google.com
Re-engagement with Customer.io$100 per monthNocustomer.io
★ Best overall

Personalisation with Appcues

Branching flows by user segment

  • The team invite for managers. Appcues is the no code product teams use to build those segmented flows, modals
  • The import screen for switchers

In short, Personalisation with Appcues is for branching flows by user segment. No starting price is listed for Personalisation with Appcues here; confirm pricing on the vendor site. Personalisation with Appcues does not include a free plan. Watch-outs: Every question costs completion, so the branching must repay the tap at once and visibly. Over segmentation produces a maintenance thicket of flows nobody owns. Appcues pricing is quote based and targeted at funded product teams. Where it shines: One flow suits nobody: the practice is to ask one or two questions a maximum of; what brought you here.

Price: See website

Free plan: No

Website: appcues.com

Watch out for

  • Smaller apps commonly implement one branch in code and skip the system
2

Permission priming with OneSignal

Asking for notifications at the right moment
Free

Think of Permission priming with OneSignal for asking for notifications at the right moment. Drawbacks to consider: a polite ask earns a polite no and at times an uninstall. System rules also constrain the pattern; Priming cannot fix a notification strategy users do not want. Price to start with Permission priming with OneSignal: Free. You can start on Permission priming with OneSignal without paying. What users get: is the standard tool for the messaging side: prompts, segments; the analytics that display opt in rate by timing. Moving the ask from minute one to the moment of value is routinely the largest single opt in gain available.

Free plan: Yes

Website: onesignal.com

Strengths

  • The first workout is logged
  • Free to start

Watch out for

  • If your pushes are marketing noise
3

Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel

Letting users reach the core action first
Free

Think of Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel for letting users reach the core action first. Limits to weigh: anything where the value is your own stored data; Some products cannot defer accounts, regulated finance, health. Upsides: ask for signup at the moment of saving, sharing; or syncing, when the account visibly buys something. Apps that wall the product behind registration convert a fraction of the curious into the annoyed. Mixpanel's free level is the measuring instrument: funnel analysis displays the exact step where the wall costs you users, which turns the argument from opinion into a chart. Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel starts at: Free. A free plan is available with Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel.

Free plan: Yes

Website: mixpanel.com

Strengths

  • The first practice is subtraction: let a new user do the core thing, browse, produce, play, calculate
  • Before demanding an account

Watch out for

  • Those apps must make the wall itself quick and justified instead. Deferred signup complicates attribution and can inflate empty account numbers later. The practice also demands engineering work on guest state and migration, which small teams must schedule honestly
4

Checklists with Intercom

Giving new users a visible path to done
$29 per seat a month

Checklists with Intercom was built for giving new users a visible path to done. Drawbacks to consider: not by clicks on the checklist itself; A checklist longer than five steps reads as homework and gets dismissed. Steps must be tracked by events. Where it shines: ordered by value, with progress shown and each step launching the real action instead of a description of it. Intercom's onboarding checklists and product tours are the typical implementation. On cost, Checklists with Intercom starts like this: $29 per seat per month. No free plan comes with Checklists with Intercom.

Free plan: No

Website: intercom.com

Strengths

  • A short checklist converts an open ended first run into a finishable task: three to five steps
  • Living inside the messenger plenty of apps already run for support. Checklists work since they make incompleteness visible, since the final step can carry the account creation or trial start that step one could not

Watch out for

  • Or users learn to tick boxes rather than doing work. Intercom's per seat pricing and breadth make it a considered purchase for onboarding alone
5

Flow experiments with Firebase

Testing onboarding variants safely
Free

Flow experiments with Firebase makes the most sense for testing onboarding variants safely. What to check first: dozens of flags nobody removes; small teams should test large differences or not at all. Remote config sprawl. What Flow experiments with Firebase does well: Onboarding opinions are endless, so the mature practice is experimentation: ship two first runs. On cost, Flow experiments with Firebase starts like this: Free. Free access exists with Flow experiments with Firebase.

Free plan: Yes

Website: firebase.google.com

Strengths

  • Split new users
  • A/B testing tied to analytics events so results read in the same console. Testing also guards you from the redesign that everyone loved in the meeting and users hated in the wild

Watch out for

  • Experiments need volume: an app with two hundred installs a week will wait months for a significant result
6

Re-engagement with Customer.io

Winning back users who stalled
$100 a month

Re-engagement with Customer.io is a good fit for winning back users who stalled. Where Re-engagement with Customer.io stands out: sent inside the first day or two whereas intent survives. Customer.io; the final practice is the rescue: a short. Drawbacks to consider: both app keeps and email providers punish it. Journeys need the event data from practice six to trigger on behaviour instead of on timers. It also cannot rescue users who left since the product was wrong for them, should not try. Re-engagement with Customer.io pricing: $100 per month. Re-engagement with Customer.io has no free tier.

Free plan: No

Website: customer.io

Strengths

  • From 100 dollars per month
  • Behaviour triggered sequence across push and email that returns to the exact step abandoned, with the value restated and the friction removed

Watch out for

  • Re-engagement has a hard ethical and practical edge: message too frequently or too desperately and you earn the uninstall and the spam complaint

FAQ

Is Personalisation with Appcues the right pick for everyone comparing app onboarding best practices?

No single tool suits every team. Personalisation with Appcues comes first because it fits branching flows by user segment, while Permission priming with OneSignal suits asking for notifications at the right moment and Value before signup, measured in Mixpanel suits letting users reach the core action first. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.

When should an app ask for notification permission?

After the user has seen a reason, never on first launch. More specifically, OneSignal or your system tooling will show the opt in rate by timing, and the difference between minute one and the moment of value is normally the largest number in the entire onboarding programme.

Should an app require signup before use?

By default, no: let the user reach the core action as a guest and ask when the account buys them something visible, saving, sync, or sharing. The Mixpanel funnel on your own app settles the argument with your own users' behaviour.

Do onboarding checklists really work?

When they are short, ordered by value, and wired to real actions, yes: they convert a vague first run into a finishable task and provide returning users a place to resume. Worth adding: keep it to five steps a maximum of, put the reward at the end, and let any step be skipped by just using the app, which should tick it automatically.

What is the cheapest option for app onboarding best practices in this list?

On published monthly entry prices, Checklists with Intercom is the lowest here at $29 per seat per month. Entry price is only part of the cost, because seats, add-ons and billing terms can change the total.

How are the tools for app onboarding best practices ordered?

The order follows typical fit for app onboarding best practices, with Personalisation with Appcues first and Re-engagement with Customer.io last, then price clarity and free access. It is editorial judgement, not a score, so another team could rank the tools differently.