HR and Workforce · Researched comparison

5 Background Check Software Options Compared on Price and Fit

TaskReports may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

This list puts First Advantage first for enterprises consolidating screening vendors. HireRight is the stronger choice for regulated industries and global hiring programs, while GoodHire suits small firms that want prices on the page. Details, prices and limits for the rest of the 5 tools are below.

On this page

Key takeaways

  • The list opens with First Advantage, aimed at enterprises consolidating screening vendors.
  • Before buying HireRight, weigh this: enterprise-focused with custom pricing.
  • None of the 5 tools, from First Advantage to Accurate, has a free plan, so budget for a subscription or use a trial.
  • For mid-market businesses wanting a screening partner, Accurate is worth a look.
  • Pricing for First Advantage, HireRight, Checkr and Accurate is quote-based, which adds a sales step before you can compare cost.

Quick comparison

ToolBest forFree planDomain
------------
First AdvantageEnterprises consolidating screening vendorsNosterlingcheck.com
HireRightRegulated industries and global hiring programsNohireright.com
GoodHireSmall firms that want prices on the pageNogoodhire.com
CheckrFirms screening at volume with speedNocheckr.com
AccurateMid-market businesses wanting a screening partnerNoaccurate.com
★ Best overall

First Advantage

Enterprises consolidating screening vendors

  • 80,000+ organizations and 200M+ screens annually
  • Combined scale of Sterling and First Advantage

In short, First Advantage is for enterprises consolidating screening vendors. The honest catch is transition friction: during a merger of this size, account teams, product roadmaps, and contract terms are all in motion, so new enterprise buyers should get commitments in writing. For buyers, the merger means one contract can now handle background checks, drug and health screening, I-9, MVR, and identity verification at global scale, with the automation Sterling aimed at candidate experience layered onto First Advantage's infrastructure. Trade-offs to know: Enterprise sales motion with no self-serve path. The numbers describe the largest background screening footprint in the industry: more than 80,000 organizations served globally, 200+ countries and territories, 200 million screens conducted annually, and roughly two-thirds of the Fortune 100 as customers. Sterling's acquisition by First Advantage closed in late 2024, and sterlingcheck.com now serves as the transition home for the combined company. Check the vendor site for First Advantage pricing; none is listed in this comparison. First Advantage has no free tier.

Price: See website

Free plan: No

Website: sterlingcheck.com

Watch out for

  • Brand transition in progress, which can confuse contracting
2

HireRight

Regulated industries and global hiring programs
See website

Think of HireRight for regulated industries and global hiring programs. HireRight is the incumbent made for complexity: more than 85 million people screened a year, coverage across 200+ countries and territories, about half of the Fortune 100 as customers, and 70+ integrations with leading ATS and HCM systems. Its strengths cluster around regulated and global hiring: DOT and FMCSA compliance, drug and health screening, Form I-9. Trade-offs to know: Enterprise-focused with custom pricing. The kind of compliance infrastructure that keeps multi-jurisdiction programs defensible. In practice, the company, taken private in 2024, positions its system as the only unified global screening option in the industry, which matters when you are running consistent programs across regions with different data and privacy rules. In daily use, customer reviews on its own site emphasize ease of ordering drug screens and the breadth of reporting. No starting price is listed for HireRight here; confirm pricing on the vendor site. There is no free plan with HireRight.

Free plan: No

Website: hireright.com

Strengths

  • 70+ ATS and HCM integrations
  • 85M+ people screened annually with 200+ country coverage

Watch out for

  • Smaller employers may find it heavier than needed
3

GoodHire

Small firms that want prices on the page
$29.99 per check

GoodHire was built for small firms that want prices on the page. Employers running fewer than 50 checks per year get custom packages, and more than 100 add-on screenings include employment and education verification, MVR, drug testing, and international checks. The main drawbacks: Preset packages need 50+ checks a year. In daily use, the main limit is structural: the preset package prices assume 50+ checks annually, so truly occasional screeners should talk to sales before assuming the sticker numbers apply. GoodHire starts at: $29.99 per check. GoodHire has no permanent free option.

Free plan: No

Website: goodhire.com

Strengths

  • Transparent per-check pricing from $29.99
  • Made for SMB simplicity

Watch out for

  • Enterprise global programs are not its strength
4

Checkr

Firms screening at volume with speed
See website

Checkr targets businesses screening at volume with speed. Checkr rebuilt background screening as a data product, and its homepage numbers display the bet premium off: more than 140,000 firms, 260 million real identities mapped handling 96% of US adults, and a +60 NPS the company calls one of the highest in B2B tech. In daily use, the company also launched Checkr Profiles, portable verified identity for individuals, which signals where screening is heading. Check the vendor site for Checkr pricing; none is listed in this comparison. No free plan comes with Checkr. Drawbacks to consider: No public pricing.

Free plan: No

Website: checkr.com

Strengths

  • Solid API and marketplace integrations
  • 140K+ companies and 260M+ mapped identities

Watch out for

  • Made for scale, so very small teams get less hand-holding
5

Accurate

Mid-market businesses wanting a screening partner
See website

Accurate targets mid-market companies wanting a screening partner. Accurate has spent nearly three decades building a reputation as the screening vendor that acts like an extension of your team instead of a software login. More specifically, Accurate has also been acquisitive, including CareerBuilder Employment Screening, which broadened its US footprint. Check the vendor site for Accurate pricing; none is listed in this comparison. Accurate does not include a free plan. Trade-offs to know: No public pricing. What users get: 16,000+ customers with a partnership-oriented service model.

Free plan: No

Website: accurate.com

Strengths

  • Solid healthcare, retail
  • Transportation verticals

Watch out for

  • Mid-market focus means less product automation than Checkr

FAQ

How are the tools for background check software ordered?

First Advantage sits first and Accurate last because the order follows typical fit for background check software, then price clarity and free access. It is a judgement call, so read each profile for fit and limits.

Does any tool for background check software here have a free plan?

No tool in this list, First Advantage and Accurate included, has a permanent free plan. Trials and quotes are the usual route, so plan a short evaluation period.

Do these tools publish their prices?

Not all of them. First Advantage, HireRight, Checkr and Accurate publish no starting price, so expect a quote request for those. The rest, GoodHire included, show a starting price, though seats and billing terms still change the final cost.

Checkr vs GoodHire: which is better?

Both are now part of the same company. Checkr fits higher-volume and platform-integrated screening programs, whereas GoodHire targets small and mid-sized companies with more straightforward setup and published pricing. Choose based on your hiring volume and how much integration you need.

Can I try these options before paying?

Not by default. None of the tools, from First Advantage to Accurate, lists a free plan or a free trial here, so ask each vendor for a demo before committing.

How much does an employment background check cost?

GoodHire publishes per-check pricing from $29.99 for an entry-level package to $94.99 for its complete package. Expect deeper checks with county, federal, and verification components to cost more per candidate.