Ecommerce · Researched comparison

Replacing Facebook Marketplace: 6 Alternatives Compared

TaskReports may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Craigslist comes first here, mainly for free local classifieds. Etsy is better for handmade and vintage, and Depop is better for vintage and trend fashion. Details, prices and limits for the rest of the 6 tools are below.

On this page

Key takeaways

  • This list starts with Craigslist, which is built for free local classifieds.
  • A fair warning about Poshmark: commission of 20 percent on sales over $15, or $2.95 under $15.
  • 6 of the 6 tools have a free plan, including Craigslist, Etsy, Depop and Poshmark.
  • No starting price is published for Etsy; expect a quote.
  • Mercari suits everyday decluttering.

Quick comparison

ToolIdeal forStarts atFree tier
------------
CraigslistFree local classifiedsFreeYes
EtsyHandmade and vintageSee websiteYes
DepopVintage and trend fashionFreeYes
PoshmarkFashion and accessoriesFreeYes
eBayNationwide and global sellingFreeYes
MercariEveryday declutteringFreeYes
★ Best overall

Craigslist

Free local classifieds

  • Capable local reach for bulky items
  • Straightforward posting with no social account needed

Pick Craigslist if this describes you: free local classifieds. The lack of protection is the honest weakness. Downsides: Higher scam and no display risk than protected marketplaces. More specifically, for bulky local goods, Craigslist is still hard to beat on cost. Entry price for Craigslist: Free. A free plan is available with Craigslist.

Price: Free

Free plan: Yes

Website: craigslist.org

Watch out for

  • No payment protection
2

Etsy

Handmade and vintage
See website

Etsy was built for handmade and vintage. Buyers come to Etsy looking for unique, handmade, or vintage items, which means a hand thrown mug, a restored lamp, or a vintage dress meets an audience that already values it. For mass produced goods, Etsy is a poor fit and may breach its handmade and vintage rules. On top of that, for genuine handmade or vintage work, the audience is worth the fee. Etsy does not show a starting price in this comparison, so check the vendor site for current pricing. Etsy has a free plan. Downsides: Listing fee of $0.20 plus a 6.5 percent transaction fee and payment processing. Main advantages: Global reach for unique goods.

Free plan: Yes

Website: etsy.com

Strengths

  • Craft supplies
  • Buyers seek handmade, vintage

Watch out for

  • Competition and ad fees can add up
3

Depop

Vintage and trend fashion
Free

Depop makes the most sense for vintage and trend fashion. Recent reports put the US seller fee at about 3.3 percent plus $0.45 per transaction, which is lower than Poshmark for numerous fashion sales. Payment terms can vary, so confirm the current fee before you list. Beyond that, Depop buyers skew younger and trend focused, so classic or formal clothing may sell more slowly than on eBay or Poshmark. On cost, Depop starts like this: Free. You can start on Depop without paying. Where it falls short: Disputes and shipping follow product rules.

Free plan: Yes

Website: depop.com

Strengths

  • Capable audience for vintage and trend led fashion
  • Visual

Watch out for

  • Audience skews younger, so not every style sells
4

Poshmark

Fashion and accessories
Free

Think of Poshmark for fashion and accessories. Buyers arrive looking for clothing, shoes, bags, and accessories, including brand names. So a well photographed closet can sell quicker here than on a general marketplace. Downsides: Needs active sharing to sell well. Poshmark takes 20 percent on sales over $15, and $2.95 on sales under $15, which is higher than Mercari or Depop for plenty of items. In practice, if you sell fashion on a regular basis and you price with the commission in mind, Poshmark provides a focused audience that general systems cannot match. Listings are simple to build, shipping labels are pre-purchased, and the social features, like sharing listings and following sellers, help new listings reach more buyers. Entry price for Poshmark: Free. Poshmark includes a free tier.

Free plan: Yes

Website: poshmark.com

Strengths

  • Social selling features help listings get seen
  • Large fashion focused audience

Watch out for

  • Or $2.95 under $15
5

eBay

Nationwide and global selling
Free

eBay is aimed squarely at nationwide and global selling. You can sell almost anything, from electronics and collectibles to clothing and home goods, to buyers across the country and around the world. For everyday use, final value fees run roughly 10 to 15 percent based on category, plus a small per order fee. Limits to weigh: Final value fees of roughly 10 to 15 percent plus a per order fee. So a $100 sale does not net $100. In practice, for rare, valuable, or niche goods, and for items that will not sell locally, eBay remains the most solid alternative, since reach commonly outweighs the fee. The listing tools, search filters, and seller protections provide both sides more structure than a local classified ad. On cost, eBay starts like this: Free. eBay includes a free tier.

Free plan: Yes

Website: ebay.com

Strengths

  • Auction and fixed price choices
  • Seller protections and structured listing tools

Watch out for

  • High competition can pressure prices
6

Mercari

Everyday decluttering
Free

Where Mercari fits: everyday decluttering. More specifically, listing is fast, the app creates a pre-purchased shipping label. The buyer pays for shipping in most cases, which removes the have to weigh a parcel or visit a post office with a custom label. On top of that, the limit is local bulky goods. Mercari cost at the entry level: Free. Mercari has a free plan.

Free plan: Yes

Website: mercari.com

Strengths

  • Straightforward listing and pre-purchased shipping labels
  • A decent match for household goods

Watch out for

  • Shipping only model fits fewer bulky items

FAQ

Which options for Facebook Marketplace have a free plan?

On this list, 6 of 6 tools include a free plan, among them Craigslist, Etsy, Depop and Poshmark. Caps on seats, usage or features are common, so test the free plan against your real workload.

What are the best alternatives to Facebook Marketplace for local selling?

The first pick on this list is Craigslist, because it suits free local classifieds. Etsy is better for handmade and vintage, and Depop for vintage and trend fashion. Check price and limits against your own needs before choosing.

Is Craigslist the right pick for everyone comparing Facebook Marketplace?

No single tool suits every team. Craigslist comes first because it fits free local classifieds, while Etsy suits handmade and vintage and Depop suits vintage and trend fashion. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.

Can I sell handmade items without Facebook Marketplace?

Yes, Etsy is aimed at handmade and vintage goods, with shop tools and a global audience that seeks unique items. Check Etsy rules for handmade and vintage eligibility before you list.

Can I try these tools before paying?

Often, yes. Craigslist, Etsy, Depop and others have a free plan. Use your own data and a real task during the test, and check what the free tier or trial limits before you rely on it.

Is it safe to sell on alternatives to Facebook Marketplace?

It can be, if you follow product safety rules. Protected marketplaces like eBay, Mercari, and Poshmark offer more dispute help than open classified sites like Craigslist, where cash and caution matter more.